My favorite mascara for the last three years has been Dior Blackout.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1afb2/1afb2925b1ca256fd7b36ff0bc0ff242019b2f42" alt=""
This little tube can get quite pricey for mascara and I have randomly bought drug store brand mascaras over the years to see if I can find anything
comparable. I never have any luck and always go back to it. The last few times I have bought it I felt like they have changed the formula slightly. So, my quest for a great drug store brand began again.
Full N' Soft was my favorite mascara in high school and college. It still is a great mascara, but I feel like it doesn't have enough mascara on the brush and I never get my lashes as full or as dark as I do with Dior Blackout.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b9705/b9705a199b6007783216e065f80178e26337445d" alt=""
I have probably tried six or seven different mascaras over the past 4 months. This last mascara spree was a success. First of all, I had a coupon at Ulta and the Maybelline mascaras were buy two, get one free. Second of all, I found the ONE.
Here is my new favorite: Maybelline XXL Pro 24 hr. Bold.
I don't usually like having too layer two different formulas, but this one is great.
And it is a savings of almost $16 compared to Dior Blackout.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1bc7c/1bc7cb2dc32daddaeff5fe5cffe367bb687fdcd4" alt=""
I had planned on taking picture of my lashes with each different formula on, but laziness won out. This was my runner up.
I love big wands, but I do have a problem with getting black specks all over my freshly shadowed eye lid. The brush may be a little too big.
Wow, my eyes look tired. Ignore them and just look at the lashes.data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a46c0/a46c0dbf15ee960bc5a1b55a1e894cd14b60fc62" alt=""
I did try mascaras that weren't the Maybelline brand, but they were no bueno. I guess I am drawn to them due to my old fave, Full N Soft.
What is your favorite mascara?